Dear Charlie,
I write to you during the solemn week following Notre Dame’s second loss to Navy during your coaching tenure. While I was depressed, outraged, and in utter disbelief in the hours after the clock wound down to 0:00, I have since had time to gather my thoughts and compose my emotions. Therefore, I am left with only one question for you.
WTF?!?
Navy. Navy. Now, I have absolute mad respect for the U.S. Naval Academy. I wish them all a blessed Veteran’s Day today and thank them for their selfless service to our great country. They are a class act every time they roll into South Bend, and they played a helluva game on Saturday. In truth, I’d rather lose to Navy than pretty much any other team on our schedule — you can’t really cheer against them, and no matter the outcome of the annual ND vs. Navy game, you can be assured that gameday will conclude with a genuine display of sportsmanship and mutual respect.
But this was not a game we should have lost. Navy is not a Top 25 team. We were. (Supposedly.) You never would have known it on Saturday; it was like the Irish didn’t even realize they were playing a game until halfway through the 4th quarter. I actually invented my own little internal monologue for your players to go with this game: “Meh, big deal, they scored a touchdown…meh, we’re fine…it’s just Navy, we’ll catch up…hmm, look at that, it’s the end of the 3rd quarter…oh crap, we’re still behind?!”
So what was the problem exactly? Were you unprepared? Because it kind of looked like it. Here is what everyone knew was going to happen on Saturday: Navy was going to run the ball. I knew that Navy was going to run the ball. My mom, dad, boyfriend, great uncle, little sister, and neighbor’s dog knew that Navy was going to run the ball. I have to assume that you had considered the possibility at some point during practice last week that Navy might run the flippin’ ball. So why, oh why, did our defense look so dreadfully unprepared to defend against the run? Do you have an explanation for why a team under the direction of an offensive mastermind such as yourself played as though they had never seen an option offense before? Do you?!
You might be tempted to blame the defense’s ineptitude on Corwin Brown and John Tenuta, and you might have something there. Something clearly isn’t clicking. But ya know what? They work for you. Figure it out, and fix it. Puh-leaaaase. This is getting embarrassing.
Speaking of embarrassing, kindly clear the spit from the corners of your mouth periodically throughout the game. That gets seriously nauseating, man — you don’t want to know what you look like in high def.
Now, the consequences of this loss have been somewhat dire. BCS game? Bye-bye. Chance to cash in on your recruiting efforts of the last four years in what may well be your last season with Clausen and Floyd? Bye-bye. Acceptable record by “Notre Dame standards?” Bye-bye. We now are finishing with three losses — if we’re lucky. Our best possible regular season record is now 9-3 . Ya know, the record you said wasn’t good enough after finishing 9-3 in your first season. The one you had printed on a couple thousand rally towels followed by the statement “not good enough.” I’m not here to argue whether or not it is good enough. That is a difficult scenario to evaluate for an IU football fan, because I’d be wetting myself if the Hoosiers ever finished with that record. All I’m saying is that you said it wasn’t good enough. You said that. It now has taken you a four-year road trip, with pit stops along the way at “abysmal” and “mediocre,” just to get back to “not good enough.”
Other consequences of this game, I’m afraid to report, have less to do with the state of Notre Dame football, but were equally disastrous. See, in the wake of this loss, I was in such a wretched state that I was forced to self-medicate with large quantities of booze and subsequently made an ass of myself on the dance floor at the Linebacker.
Therefore, I hereby issue to you the following sanctions:
1) You will need to post your game plan on the team website for the Irish Nation’s review and approval. It’s not that we don’t trust your judgment, it’s just…okay, yeah, we don’t trust your judgment anymore.
2) I am sending you my Saturday night bar tab of $33.25, as well as a bill for an undisclosed amount representing damages to reputation resulting from ensuing photographs. (See attached.)
Kindly remit payment no later than this Friday by 5:00 p.m. (I am anticipating I will need the money following this weekend’s game.)
3) Please, for the love of God, beat Pitt on Saturday so that Mark May shuts up for one week.
Sincerely,
Carly “Bring-Back-Lou” Reust